A few days ago I wrote a column trying to clear up the campaign debate over the value of having "direct talks" with Iran, North Korea, etc.
The Obama-Biden team, I wrote, had not been clear about what it means, which I thought opened them to phony charges of "appeasement."
What both sides should agree on is what "direct talks" mean, for the good of the country, if not themselves. It does not mean, as Obama has carelessly implied in some interviews, sitting down with, say, Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, without pre-summit talks.
Of course, there are always pre-summit talks, also called "preparation," and these are done -- Yes, Virginia - without preconditions. Given all the e-mail I've gotten, I guess I didn't make that clear.
As Richard Nixon and Henry Kissinger, who refined "direct talks" with their secret dialogue with China, have often said, you cannot find out what the other guy wants, and tell him what you want, without first sitting down "without preconditions."
Think of it in terms of Tony and Phil, in The Sopranos. First they send emissaries to lay out their position. If they still have problems, then they have the sit-down. If that doesn't work, then they apply a little pressure.
If that doesn't work, then they whack the guy. But hey, ya gotta try to tawk first.
What Would Tony Soprano Do About Iran?
By Jeff Stein | October 7, 2008 3:03 PM | Permalink | Comments (0)
Tags: Biden, China, direct talks, Iran, Kissinger, McCain, negotiations, Nixon, North Korea, Obama, Palin, Sopranos
CQ Politics Blog Network
- Bringing together unique voices from across the political spectrum.
- Poll Tracker
- SpyTalk
- David Corn
- Craig Crawford
- Taegan Goddard
- Politics (Un)Seriously
- In Transition
- Web Picks
Recent Posts
- Monday Afternoon Quarterback
- CIA Chief on Transition Danger: 'No Chatter' from Qaeda Right Now
- Obama National Security Transition Leader Close to Petraeus
- Iran in South America: How Much a Threat?
- The Spy Game Meets the Great Mentioner
- U.S. Marine Intelligence Analyst Honored for Valor on Veterans Day
- Monday Afternoon Quarterback
Subscribe to RSS feed
Posts by month
Search this blog
Links
- ABC Investigative Team
- Abu Aardvark
- Association of Former Intelligence Officers
- Attackerman
- CI Centre
- CounterTerrorism Blog
- Danger Room
- Dan Moldea
- Deep Background
- Human Rights Watch
- Intel Center
- Intelligence Online (Paris)
- Iraqslogger
- Investigative Reporters & Editors
- Mario Profaca
- McClatchy DC
- Military Bloggers
- MoJo Wire
- National Security Archive
- Nieman Watchdog
- Planet War
- Raw Story
- Secrecy News
- Sic Semper Tyrannis
- ThreatsWatch
- TPM Muckraker
- War & Peace
- Washington Babylon
- Washington Independent
- Wired/Threat Level
Post A Comment