In the moments after she announced she would resign the governorship of Alaska, MSNBC political analyst Pat Buchanan compared Sarah Palin to Richard Nixon in 1966.
Nixon returned from exile following his loss in the 1962 California gubernatorial election -- "You won't have Dick Nixon to kick around anymore" -- to win the presidency in 1968. "We traveled all over the country on behalf of Republican candidates, built up this enormous good will," Buchanan said of a 1966 Nixon barnstorming tour that helped lay the groundwork for his bid two years later.
Buchanan, an aide to Nixon at the time and in the White House, knows better. Palin is no Nixon.
She doesn't have six years to quietly work the conservative party machinery while making public statements that pin the president to his base and, by comparison, reposition her and her party as the center.
To capitalize on political backlash, as Nixon did with civil rights and Vietnam, a candidate has to represent an aggrieved center against a perceived ideological fringe. More than any other major party nominee for president or vice president in recent memory, Palin is the fringe.
It's true that running for re-election, perhaps in a tough environment in 2010, would have made it more difficult for Palin to do the necessary legwork for a 2012 presidential bid.
But running from the governorship -- rather than for it -- is hardly a recommendation for the presidency. It's like walking into a job interview as an air traffic controller and telling the hiring authority that you quit your last job as a crossing guard because the pressure was getting to be too much.
What of the Alaska voters who thought she would fulfill at least the one term to which she was elected? Right now, it looks like Wasilla mayor was the toughest job Palin could finish. Maybe, just maybe, she has abandoned her plans to run for the White House and was simply bowing out for good.
But if not, her resignation was a mistake.
"Former Alaska" anything is hardly what you want to be introduced as in a presidential debate -- just ask Former Alaska Sen. Mike Gravel.
And, as Nixon once said, "A man is not finished when he is defeated. He is finished when he quits."
Buchanan may not have written it, but he's surely heard it.
More from CQ Politics
Comments
Name recognition, money and organization are essential to win in politics. It is impossible to believe that Sarah Palin has future in Republican politics. While she has name recognition, there is more downsides than up within the GOP. There will be competition for money and organization and the smart money and people will invest in someone in the field that is smarter.
A failed VP bid and quitting mid term as Governor are hardly accomplishments that will garner support within the GOP forget attempting to run against the Democratic Party who are watching a Republican Party that has members committing suicide on a regular basis.
The only Republican I see that is attempting to change the message and agenda is Joe Scarbough and he may emerge as a viable choice. The wild card in 2012 will be the economy and how well Obama continues to manage the bad news and avoid taking the blame for the disaster he inherited. The GOP is still seen as part of the problem rather than the solution and if they continue down that path then the Whitehouse will remain out their grasp for a long time.
Good bye Sarah Palin you are an addition by subtraction for the GOP who did not need the distraction and baggage you brought to the party.
I only hope that there is not some underlying health issue that drove Governor Palin to her decision, but just plain stupidity and ego.
Comments
Name recognition, money and organization are essential to win in politics. It is impossible to believe that Sarah Palin has future in Republican politics. While she has name recognition, there is more downsides than up within the GOP. There will be competition for money and organization and the smart money and people will invest in someone in the field that is smarter.
A failed VP bid and quitting mid term as Governor are hardly accomplishments that will garner support within the GOP forget attempting to run against the Democratic Party who are watching a Republican Party that has members committing suicide on a regular basis.
The only Republican I see that is attempting to change the message and agenda is Joe Scarbough and he may emerge as a viable choice. The wild card in 2012 will be the economy and how well Obama continues to manage the bad news and avoid taking the blame for the disaster he inherited. The GOP is still seen as part of the problem rather than the solution and if they continue down that path then the Whitehouse will remain out their grasp for a long time.
Good bye Sarah Palin you are an addition by subtraction for the GOP who did not need the distraction and baggage you brought to the party.
I only hope that there is not some underlying health issue that drove Governor Palin to her decision, but just plain stupidity and ego.
Posted by: geek
| July 3, 2009 9:51 PM
The left wouldn't have attacked her so viciously if it didn't make a wholly different assessment of her chances of winning.
Posted by: Sebaneau
| July 6, 2009 12:42 PM
Of course, the left includes RINOS
http://curtislowe.files.wordpress.com/2008/02/humpday-ele-rino.jpg
Posted by: Sebaneau
| July 6, 2009 12:58 PM
Post A Comment