Results tagged “torture” from SpyTalk

Spies Vs. Spies: How the ACLU Got the Photos

| | Comments (0)

Someday somebody will make a thriller about human rights counterspies turning tables on the CIA, tracking down its interrogators and supplying dossiers on them to defense lawyers for the detainees at Guantanamo Bay.

According to reports in The Washington Post and New York Times, the Justice Department has launched an investigation of the attorneys and human rights sleuths, who even secretly photographed interrogators outside their homes and supplied pictures for the detainees to identify.

The Justice Department's implication, of course, is that something illegal was done by the John Adams Project, a collaborative effort by the American Civil Liberties Union and National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers.

But was it?

CIA Torture Scandal: Day Four

| | Comments (0)

The opening salvos on the partially declassified CIA Inspector General's report on detainee abuses included hair-raising anecdotes about threatening captives with power drills, guns to the head and the mock deaths of other prisoners.

Now the story is the dogs under the porch: what's beneath all those blacked-out paragraphs in the still heavily redacted, 2004 report by the spy agency's IG.

Massive New File of Interrogation Documents

| | Comments (0)

The National Security Archive, a nonprofit research center at George Washington University, today released a massive file of more than 83,000 pages of primary source documents "related to the detention and interrogation of individuals by the United States, in connection with the conduct of hostilities in Iraq and Afghanistan as well as in the broader context of the 'global war on terror.'"

Interrogations Shake-Up: Blair Needs a HIG

| | Comments (0)

It's hard to find any clear winners in the new interrogations set-up confirmed by the White House on Monday, but it's easy to spot the losers: Leon Panetta and Dennis Blair.

Spy Agencies Bump Heads Over Interrogations

| | Comments (3)

The White House beat a strategic retreat last week on its ideas for a new multiagency interrogation unit, giving its task force another two months to come up with a plan everybody can live with.

But if initial reactions are any guide, the White House faces an uphill fight in creating an organization that can satisfy military, intelligence and law enforcement needs at once.
U.S. and European officials have been at war over the wording of the Geneva Convention ever since American forces invaded Afghanistan in late 2001 and began rounding up terrorist suspects and Taliban fighters.

Maybe it's time for a new Geneva Convention for the age of terrorism.
Former Vice President Dick Cheney has taken to many stumps lately to proclaim that the CIA's "enhanced interrogation techniques" saved the United States from another terrorist attack.

That leaves the question of what prevented another terrorist attack after the torture, as some call it, of terrorist suspects stopped.
A former deep-cover CIA operative says the spy agency's congressional briefers routinely shade the truth or hide facts altogether from congressional overseers.

"They mumble, they dissemble, and there's a lot of  'on the one hand . . .'" said the retired official, who spent 25 years as a CIA operations officer but now writes blistering, unauthorized critiques of the spy agency using the pen name "Ishmael Jones."
In the continuing cacophony over what torture is and whether it "works," an important point has gone missing, say current and former counterterrorism operatives.

The CIA's reliance on repeated, and brutal, "enhanced" interrogation techniques shows how few spies the spy agency had before and after the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks.

That made the agency's reliance on squeezing new information out of captured terrorist suspects all the more desperate, many say.

The Guantanamo Officers' Club

| | Comments (2)

About 20 years ago I had the privilege to interview Gen. George L. Mabry, the second most decorated soldier in the history of the U.S. Army, at his home in Columbia, S.C.

Mabry had been awarded the Medal of Honor for his heroics in World War Two. The young captain had already earned a chestful of ribbons for his "Saving Private Ryan" performance at Utah Beach on June 6, 1944. Only the legendary Audie Murphy earned more medals.

But five months later, in the Huertgen Forest near Schevenhutte, Germany, Mabry, 27, raced past his forward observers to cut through some mine-rigged Concertina wire

Clearing a path for his soldiers, and he then captured three enemy bunkers in succession, killing three German soldiers, disabling another with his rifle butt and another with his bayonet. He captured nine other Germans.

You can read the entire citation at the Medal of Honor site, here.

What you will not read in his citation is what he told me in his quiet study, only months before he died in 1990.
There are 14 names in the confidential Red Cross report that surfaced last week on the CIA's "ill treatment" of detainees.

But you will not find in it the name of Manadel al-Jamadi, an Iraqi who was picked up by U.S. Navy SEALS in Baghdad and interrogated by the CIA.

That's because Jamadi died in the care of Mark Swanner, a 44-year-old CIA interrogator who battered the prisoner at the ghastly Abu Ghraib in 2003. 
The Italian prosecutor who has been trying two dozen CIA agents on kidnapping charges says he will continue the case, despite a high court decision Wednesday that excludes the use of wiretapped conversations among top Italian intelligence officials.

Armando Spataro, reached by telephone on a train between Rome and Milan, said,  "the trial will go on" despite the Constitutional Court's decision excluding transcripts in which intelligence officials discussed a CIA plan for the  "extraordinary rendition" of an al Qaeda suspect from a Milan street to an Egyptian prison in 2003.
The former head of the CIA unit charged with liquidating Osama Bin Laden said that national security officials in the Clinton administration "had no qualms" about transferring al Qaeda suspects to countries with reputations for torture.

Michael F. Scheuer
, who worked on finding Bin Laden from 1996 to his retirement in 2004, made the allegation during an April 17, 2007 House Foreign Affairs Subcommittee hearing on the treatment of terrorism suspects picked up by the CIA.

"I know there was much more consideration under the Bush administration about how to handle these people than there was under the Clinton administration, sir," Scheuer maintained in response to a question from Rep. Bill Delahunt, D-Mass., the panel's chairman.

"There were no qualms at all about sending people to Cairo," he said, adding that there was a "kind of joking up our sleeves about what would happen to those people in Cairo in Egyptian prisons, sir."
"Far more secret memos" on hard interrogations, detention and warrantless wiretapping programs have been discovered, most originating in the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel (OLC), according to a new report.

And Attorney General Eric H. Holder, Jr., confirmed Monday, has indicated that a number of them may be made public.
I'm a little late getting to this, what with everything else going on in the intelligence world, but an investigation by Mexico-based U.S. freelance reporter Kristin Bricker on the American contractors caught on video teaching torture techniques to police in Leon deserves belated attention.

Bricker has identified one of the men, Gerardo "Jerry" Arrechea as a "high-ranking member of the Comandos F4,"  a Miami based anti-Castro exile group that has vowed to carry out armed attacks on Cuba as well as Venezuela. 

Cuban exile groups long ago perfected the p.r. stunt of inviting TV cameras to "secret locations" in the Everglades to show their masked men crawling through mud with guns and vowing to overthrow Castro. But it's also true that the CIA has intermittently intrigued with such groups for half a century. 

Meanwhile, the rest of the connections Bricker turned up on Arrechea and his sidekick Jerry Wilson (AKA Orlando, AKA Andrew Wilson), last seen dragging a Mexican police trainee through his own vomit, are yet another sign that U.S. private security contractors are out of control. 

(Take a peek at my recent review of Tim Shorrock's Spies for Hire: The Secret World of Intelligence Outsourcing, in The Washington Post, then read the rest of Bricker's comprehensive take.)



The National Intelligence Directorate late Friday released a "recent" letter from Joel F. Brenner, its counterintelligence chief, to the New York Times, calling its rationale for identifying a CIA interrogator by name in a June story "nonsense" and "morally confused."

"The Times also trivialized the risk to the man by putting him to the impossible burden of showing with near certainty that he would be harmed," wrote Brenner, who heads the National Counterintelligence Executive (NCIX). "This was morally confused. This man and many others like him undertake difficult, dangerous, and lawful missions on behalf of their country, and they deserve better from The Times."

The letter, posted on the DNI Web site, was not dated, nor was it printed by The Times, a search of its Web site indicated.

On June 22, The Times published a feature story by reporter Scott Shane describing a skillful interrogation of 9/11 mastermind Khalid Shaikh Mohammed by a CIA analyst it identified as Deuce Martinez. The paper said it helped protect Martinez by using only his nickname.

"A sobbing Canadian teenager begged for help as he was interrogated at the US 'war on terror' camp at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, in the very first video glimpse of any such questioning released on Tuesday," AFP reports.

The video was posted online by attorneys for terror suspect Omar Khadr, who is shown being questioned at the prison by Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) agents in February, 2003. He was 16 years old.
Khadr, accused of killing a US soldier in a firefight in Afghanistan, has been held at Gitmo since his arrest in 2002, when he was 15 years old.

"Help me, help me, help me," Khadr says in the video, weeping, holding his head in his hands.

Hitchens Cracks Quickly In Waterboarding Lark

| | Comments (0)

Writer Christopher Hitchens beat cigarettes this year, but he couldn't take  waterboarding for more than a few seconds.  

In the new Vanity Fair, the prolific British ex-pat describes how underwent a waterboarding experiment in the hands of tough U.S. counterterrorism experts at a secret site in Western North Carolina in May.

He says that he's embarrased at how little time it took for him to crack and trigger the pre-arranged "stop signal." but in the disturbing video on VF's Web site I counted it out at 13 seconds.

The interrogators would hardly have had time to ask me any questions, and I knew that I would quite readily have agreed to supply any answer. 

The operative words here are any answers. As I wrote earlier this week, 15 top fomer FBI, CIA and military interrogation specialists meeting in Washington last week declared that one reason torture isn't very useful is that its subjects will say anything to stop the pain -- there's no guarantee that any of it is the truth. 

Until his own experiment, the influential Hitchens labelled waterboarding  merely "extreme interrogation." But the headline on the VF piece is, "Believe Me, It's Torture."

Hitchens' interrogators warned him that even his brief experiment could have lasting effects. 

And so it has.

I have since woken up trying to push the bedcovers off my face, and if I do anything that makes me short of breath I find myself clawing at the air with a horrible sensation of smothering and claustrophobia. 

Hitchens allowed to his interrogator that he felt shame from surrendering when just a cup or less of water was dripped onto the towel over his face. 

The man gently told him, "Any time is a long time when you're breathing water."

Says Hitchens now: "If waterboarding does not constitute torture, then there is no such thing as torture."

Abu Omar is broke, and emailing people for help.

Omar is a suspected al Qaeda operative who in 2003 was kidnapped off a street in Milan, Italy by CIA agents and secretly flown to Cairo for a hard interrogation by Egyptian security forces, overseen by a CIA official.

Now free but physically broken -- he has shown his wounds to visiting reporters -- Omar took to the Internet from Egypt last week and began e-mailing human rights organizations, the United Nations and bloggers who have written about his case, asking for financial help with bringing his family together.

I received mine last Saturday, June 21, having written extensively about the case.

In the battle for public opinion on torture, Joe Navarro doesn't stand a chance against Jack Bauer.

The hero of the Fox action series "24," now entering its seventh season, seems to have cast a spell over the country -- including high level Pentagon, CIA and White House officials who continue to insist that torture works, despite all evidence to the contrary.

People, it's fiction!

Joe Navarro, on the other hand, is the real deal, an FBI counterterrorism veteran who's gone mano-a-mano in prison cells with many a bad guy.

"There are a lot of people that think that torture and pushing people around and just being nasty gets the work done," Navarro said during an almost completely ignored seminar at the Center for Strategic and International Studies last week

"I assure you, I have never had anybody confess to me who said, well, I decided to confess to you because you treated me like crap. It just doesn't happen that way."

Another tough hombre on the panel, Ken Robinson, who spent 20 years in black ops with the Army Rangers, Special Forces, CIA and NSA, said bluntly: "It doesn't work."

Why do so many people think it does?

Rage Against the Machine

| | Comments (0)

Ever since I attended a conference on homeland security in Paris four years ago, I've been fascinated by how little the French, Italians, Germans and other continentals seem to worry about violations of their civil rights by their spy agencies.

Outside the United Kingdom, which invented civil liberties with the Magna Carta 993 years ago last Sunday, ordinary Europeans by and large couldn't care less about wiretapping, national ID cards and police spies in mosques, all of which have millions of Americans, not to mention the ACLU and libertarian Rep. Ron Paul , R-Texas, up in arms.

As I reported Friday in my regular SpyTalk column, two leading European judicial figures with vast experience in terrorism cases, French magistrate Jean-Louis Bruguière, and Italy's Armando Spataro, the Milan prosecutor who has put al Qaeda operatives, mafiosi, Marxist terrorists and CIA operatives alike on trial, agree. But readers are already fine-tuning, to put it kindly, my arguments, which you can find at the bottom of the column.

All in all, It's a fine beginning for the SpyTalk blog. Stir it up.