Tonight, a United States senator will be elected president for the first time since John F. Kennedy in 1960. The curse that usually keeps them out of the White House - the long records of votes and speeches that can be used against them, the lapses into Senate-speak that can alienate voters on the campaign trail — will be broken.
But did the voters get a true picture of the Barack Obama and John McCain we’ve seen in the Senate? Not really — and not just because voters have been asked to believe Obama is a closet socialist and McCain is President Bush’s identical twin.
The deeper problem is that their own campaigns distort their personalities. Once they go out on the road, presidential candidates become the equivalent of businesses, with all of the employees’ fortunes riding on their success. And in this case, the employees are political operatives who, by their nature, can’t rise above politics as usual.
In the Senate, and in Springfield before that, Obama has been a politician with a generally liberal record but a moderate temperament. Yes, he almost always voted with Senate Democrats on measures that divided the parties - 97 percent of the time in 2005, 96 percent of the time in 2006, and 97 percent of the time again last year. But he also gained a reputation as a good listener, a quick study and a diligent worker (until he started running for president).
And anyone who can form friendships and working partnerships with Republicans like Tom Coburn of Oklahoma and Richard G. Lugar of Indiana, as Obama did, is probably capable of genuine bipartisanship, and on bigger issues than Obama tackled in the Senate.
Yet you’d hardly know that from watching Obama on the campaign trail. Yes, we’ve seen signs of the intellect, maturity and good sportsmanship his colleagues have seen from him at an early age. But even as Obama has vowed to challenge “the smallness of our politics,” his campaign has blasted out e-mails every day that thrive in that smallness of politics — pouncing on McCain’s smallest slips of the tongue, chasing the distraction of the day, bragging about the size of Obama’s crowds compared to McCain’s.
And Obama’s claim that McCain’s health care plan would require $882 billion in cuts to Medicare, based on nothing more than a liberal think tank’s guess, bore almost no resemblance to the high standards the real Obama has usually set for public policy debates. The only conclusion one can draw is that the operatives were calling the shots on that one.
The McCain of the Senate, meanwhile, has gotten such a complete makeover in this campaign that he might as well be someone else.
The real McCain has always been conservative at his core, but with enough of an independent streak to constantly rethink issues and challenge his party not to be afraid of working with the other side. That makes him a genuinely complicated character, one who would be a real challenge to capture accurately in any campaign narrative.
But instead of trying, the McCain team, chock-full of standard Republican operatives, has spent most of the campaign trying to make him look like a generic Republican. Everything that was unique about him — the open-mindedness, the rebelliousness, the candor, the casual banter with the press, the senatorial courtesy to his political opponents — got swept aside, one by one. About all that was left of the real McCain was the combative side, and that rarely charms anybody who doesn’t already agree with you.
Sure, McCain talked about his record of bipartisan work, which is real and covers more significant issues than Obama’s. So why didn’t that resonate more with voters? Maybe because a candidate who spends so much time depicting his opponent as a socialist doesn’t sound like a bipartisan guy. All along, McCain’s challenge was to figure out how to throw out all the red meat the conservative base demands while also preserving his independence. He appears to have found the answer: You can’t.
If Obama wins tonight, he’ll have much more freedom to rise above “the smallness of our politics” and realize the potential he has demonstrated in the Senate. The same is true of McCain, if he pulls off a major political upset. But it will only happen if the next president tells his operatives: You had your turn running the show. Now it’s my turn.